These girls have the lowest rated cards/shows on virtuagirl, but are they really that bad? According to the voters on the card pages they really suck, but what about the forum users? I for one have most of these shows and although some shows are much too short or feature somewhat silly outfits/moves, I like most of them with Dorothy Bank, Lucie T and Maggie as favorites.

This looks like fun! Thanks Member.

I donot own any of these cards, but some others from these girls. Katrina"s Wild kitten is one of my favs, but I passed on her other cards...Maggie too is nice and own 3 of her cards and like them all...Lucie T is a different story, I have Barvarian Party which is OK, the outfit struck my interest, her other looks just didn't interest me.

Easy choice for me. I actually like Lilliane Tiger's card, even if it is not a favourite.

I don't own (any) Ting and fireman Sam G, so no comment there (except that the fireman outfit and show length are a major reason for me not buying Carol).

I like Lucie T's slender body, beautifully shaped breasts and light skin color. Her shows aren't sparkling or something but if you look you can enjoy her appearance quite easily.

Karina's got remarkable nipples on her well rounded breasts, she's got a good body but is a bit short. Her shows are average and have lots of short clips as far as I can remember. But a beautiful woman nonetheless.

Dorothy Bank is my vote in this poll, she's somewhat too slender maybe, but the shape of her body, breasts and pussy are mouth-watering. Also a big plus is she's got a great smile, I'm a sucker for girls smiling (which incidentally is why Liliane Tiger is not among my favorites, I've only seen her smile once).

Maggie has that girl-next-door look, big blue eyes and a nice though a bit skinny set of hips. Again a beautiful body but for me a bit too skinny. It's a shame her shows, as well as Lucie's and Silver's are a bit too soft.

Lucie T - Copacabana

Lucie is beautiful. Her card ratings really ***** though from her lack of explicit content. Many on this site don't give good ratings to cards with little explicit content, and she is shyer than most. Not me though, because I gave this card a 10!

i think the most reason for the low ratings are the bad outfits or ***** hairstyles. some are surely underrated.
the most of the cards above are from the beginning of vghd, in this time the shows are not so long as they are later.

it was long long ago that i saw these shows fully so i can't vote for one.
but i think for me it's between Karina and Liliane Tiger.

Well, of course everyone knows I think the sun rises and sets just to make Ting happy, as for the others ...
Four of those ladies have some of my very favorite clips.
I like the outfits and the girls seem to have fun dancing across my desktop.
The votes don't mean a thing to me. Everyone here has their own "type" of girl or outfit or even style of acting/dancing that they prefer.

I agree with SpaveInvader: 2 strong reasons are bad outfits and/or ***** hairstyles. Maggie and Dorothy are examples. Their low rated shows feature costume-funkiness (Maggie’s pants) and unappealing hair treatments (Dorothy’s scarf, Maggie’s hairdo).

In addition, as Wolffrnd said, some of these girls are rated low because they aren’t very explicit. I personally add (.66) to the rating of non-explicit models to get a ‘truer’ grasp of their shows (because I don’t mind non-explicit shows. I have plenty of both varieties.) Example: Bernadette’s Glasgow Student is rated 8.69. Add the non-explicit factor and you get 8.69 plus .66 = 9.35, which puts this card where it belongs, imho, among the best.

Some cards are downgraded because the run time is too short. Anything under 30mins is considered short.

1 more reason is the model’s personality, which can ***** the passions her looks stir. Liliane Tiger fits this category. She’s kinda scary and sullen, rather than sexy and sultry, and never smiles. I like her, find her attractive and deserving of a mid-8s score.

Some low rated cards ***** from most or all of these flaws. Perhaps Silver exemplifies this. I don’t have any of her shows, but presume she’s not very explicit. ‘Young Bride’ is only 16 mins, and according to reviews the clips are short and choppy. I suggest Totem permanently reduce this card to 1 ticket, as they did with Maggie’s short show, Trendy Pub.

I believe what will come out in the end is that each of these girls is somebody’s favorite, and it should feel like Totem reached out and plucked her just for you.

I would have bought all of Carol G's cards if they weren't so short. She's a knockout.

Sure I have my Favorites here on VG like everyone else.
but for me, I can't say there is a single card that I don't like.
Every cards has something to offer.
Some I like more than others, but there isn't a single card that I can say I'm disappointed to own.

lol,my bad, cannot see straight with all that clutter,meant to click on Karina, but too late ,lol

@doomtank1: lol! What girl got your vote now? Jennifer?

I don`t have any of these card the only one I have is Elya and it is not that good.

@readyforanything:

How can you have none of these cards and still have the Elya card? I'm puzzled.

Carol G , Karina and Dorothy Bank are all wonderful girls particularly Karina because of her mastery of the pole .
With that in mind the only card of this group that I've bought is Dorothy Bank -Pirate City . I rated it a 9 @time of purchase .
So that's the best of the worst!!

The BEST thing about the WORST costumes is that they come off. The hairdo stays.
(photo from Young Wife).

Dorothy, Karina & Lucie take a clear lead over the rest. It's a good thing Silver got 1 vote, it would be sad to be a young bride with no groom!
Very nice pic there Tacia, even though the show may not be great the pictures can be excellent.

That's a very good point, Member84'. The videos and photo sets can be significantly different from the animation. Maggie's photos are much more explicit than her shows.

Morgane's 'Flashy Babe' is a good example (from the other end of the spectrum - Best of the Best). In the photo set her hair is wet, and while they probably achieved the 'setting' they were after, Morgane looks more bedraggled than sexy.

Ting's cabaret is a good example where the photo set is different from the animation. In the photos she is wearing panties. But in the animation there is none. Big dissapointment. Just like zafira's Ivory Goddess.

In saying, that it can work the other way round and get a pleasant surprise as happened with one of Pussykat's cards.

Generally, I really like Ting because to me she looks very erotic, but a normal girl at the same time. I also generally like Dorothy banks and have a high opinion of some of her cards.. It's just the Pirate City costume is so unappealling.

I didn't buy any Ting yet, but your description makes me think about it Apasas. At least she's real and not fake like Pussykat.

I have 1 of Ting’s cards ‘Yellow Sea’ (I only have 1 card of each of girl in my collection). Ting’s wearing 1 of the tiniest bikinis on the site. She’s a really cute girl with a nicely proportioned body. She’s smiling and cheery and sexy all at once.

I'd like to point out that Silver's card is no. 4 on this VGHD site. The hair was still quite funky back then... maybe???;)
Many of these cards are quite old (some appear with VG 2 logos) and this might go some way towards explaining why they don't sell well. Stars and fashions come and go.
I thought that Silver was quite charming when I brought her and thoroughly enjoyed all her cards. I know the same was said of Karina, Elya and Lucie T...

Yes good point shodan084, but sometimes outfits are so old they become hot again, like Bernadette's Roman Empire ;-)

By the way, speaking of funny outfits, i'd have expected Divine's Pumpkin Day or Sandra Sanchez' Marvel Land to be in this row outfit-wise. I guess those girls are hot enough to make up for the outfit?

Out of this group, Karina's the only one I'm messing with right now. I have all her cards except the one pictured above: Miss Mystery. I really like her playfulness and dancing style. The fake boobs is the only possible deal-breaker for me, oh and that damn dog on the red outfit card. I de-selected all clips with that dog in it.

My runner up here would be Dorothy Bank. I like model-types and she fits the bill. That scarf is some high-fashion stuff and not everyone gets that or is into that.

Divine's been dropped. Sandra's Marvel Land is probably 11th. Here's a chart showing the rating and the length of the shows, with Marvel Land included. I see some correlation, where longer shows might be boosting the rating.

Ranking by Rating - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Ranking by length of show
Jennifer Galbina - Orange Soda..5.07 - - - - - - - - -Elya - Sporty Day…………….……...16mins
Silver - Young Bride….…....…….5.88 - - - - - - - - -Silver - Young Bride……….…….…..16mins
Elya - Sporty Day………..….......6.55 - - - - - - - - Karina - Miss Mystery…….………...19mins
Liliane Tiger – Scandal…….…....6.80 - - - - - - - - Maggie - Young Wife…………….…..20mins
Karina - Miss Mystery………......6.92 - -- - - - - -- Carol G - Under Fire…………...........23mins
Dorothy Bank - Pirate City..........6.92 - - - - - - - - Lucie T - Copacabana………………..24mins
Carol G - Under Fire…............…6.95 - - - - - - - - Jennifer Galbina - Orange Soda.....…25mins
Ting – Cabaret……………….......6.98 - - - - - - - - Sandra Sanchez – Marvel land.….....32mins
Maggie - Young Wife……..…......7.07 - - - - - - - - Dorothy Bank - Pirate City……….….33mins
Lucie T – Copacabana….…….....7.26- - - - - - - - Liliane Tiger – Scandal...……………..34mins
Sandra Sanchez – Marvel land....7.34 - - - - - - - - Ting - Cabaret…………….….………..53mins